Let me start with a sentence you have heard, maybe at a funeral, maybe from a friend who does not believe: “You just have to have faith.”
What do people usually mean by that? Most of the time they mean: believe it even though there is no reason to. Close your eyes and jump. Faith as the opposite of knowing.
Today I want to show you that this is not what the Bible means by faith. We will take it in two steps. First, a man who was an atheist, C. S. Lewis, will show us that the evidence for God starts inside you. Then the apostle John will show us that the evidence continues in a Man you can place on a map and on a calendar.
Lewis begins somewhere very ordinary: a quarrel.
Listen to people argue. “That's my seat, I was here first.” “You promised.” “How would you like it if somebody did that to you?” Notice what is going on. The person is not just saying I don't like what you did. He is appealing to a standard he expects the other person to know already. And the other person almost never answers, “Who cares about fair?” He says, “That's not what happened,” or “I had a good reason.” Both of them assume the rule is real.
People used to call that rule the law of nature, meaning the law of human nature. Lewis then sets it beside the other laws of nature, the ones science studies, and shows how different they are.
| Laws of nature | The law of human nature |
|---|---|
| Gravity, heat, motion | Fairness, keeping promises, not betraying a friend |
| Tell you what does happen | Tell you what ought to happen |
| A stone cannot disobey gravity | A man can disobey, and does |
| Learned by watching from the outside | Known from the inside, by every one of us |
Drop a stone and it falls. It never ought to fall. It just does. But you and I live under a law we are free to break. Lewis says two facts sit underneath all clear thinking about ourselves:
- People everywhere know they ought to behave a certain way.
- People everywhere do not actually behave that way.
Keep those two facts in mind. The whole lesson stands on them.
Lewis takes on the two easy answers people give.
“It's just instinct, like a herd animal.” But think about what happens when you hear someone shouting for help in the water. You feel two instincts: one to help, and one to stay safe. Then a third thing tells you that you ought to follow the first and not the second. That third thing cannot be one of the instincts. It is the thing that judges between them. Lewis compares it to a piano. The instincts are the keys. The moral law is the sheet music that tells you which key to strike.
“It's just what society taught you.” Society does teach it to us, the way it teaches us multiplication. That does not make multiplication made up. And here is the giveaway: we all say some societies were better than others. We say ending slavery was progress. You cannot say one idea is better than another unless both are measured against a real standard outside them both. You can't say a ruler got closer to twelve inches if there is no such thing as twelve inches.
None of this would surprise Paul. He wrote it down nineteen hundred years before Lewis was born.
“The work of the law is written on their hearts.” That is Lewis's first fact. People who never heard of Moses still know what fair is.
And that is Lewis's second fact, from an apostle's own mouth: I know what is right, and I don't do it.
Scripture speaks of two books God has written. One is outside us:
The other is inside us:
Now Lewis makes his main move. Science looks at the universe from the outside. It can tell you what happens, but it cannot tell you why there is anything at all, or whether anyone is behind it. Science is not built to answer that.
But there is one thing in the whole universe we know from the inside: ourselves. And when we look inside, we do not just find facts. We find a command. We find that we are under a law we did not invent and cannot get rid of.
A law means a lawgiver. A command means Someone who commands. And this Someone cares about right and wrong, about fairness, and about truth. Lewis says this is a clue to the meaning of the universe. It is not yet the whole answer.
And it is not comfortable news. If there is a real law and I have broken it, then I am not a neutral observer. I am in trouble. Lewis says Christianity makes no sense until you have felt that.
God promised He would deal with exactly that:
Here is where Lewis's argument stops. It can bring you to the door: there is Someone behind the law. It cannot tell you His name. For that we need a witness.
Turn to John. Listen to how he begins:
“The true light, which gives light to everyone.” That is the light Lewis found in every human heart, the law every one of us already knows. John says it comes from the Word. And then he says the most important sentence in the book:
“The Word became flesh.” The Someone behind the moral law did not stay a clue. He became a Man. And John adds: “we have seen.” Not “we have felt.” Not “we have imagined.” We have seen.
Now watch how John writes. He keeps putting his story where you can check it.
A Person. Not an idea, not a feeling. A man from a real town, with a real father's name, that a skeptic sneered at:
Notice Philip's answer to the doubter. Not “just have faith.” “Come and see.” And John remembers the very hour he first met Jesus:
“About the tenth hour.” About four in the afternoon. That is not how legends are written. That is how an old man remembers the day his life changed.
A Place. John names spots in Jerusalem with their details:
For years critics said John's five-colonnaded pool at Bethesda was invented. Then excavations beside the Church of St. Anne in Jerusalem uncovered a large double pool with colonnades, just where John put it. The Pool of Siloam from Jesus' day was uncovered by workers repairing a sewer line in 2004. And John gives the Stone Pavement its Aramaic name, Gabbatha. That is the kind of detail a man who never walked those streets would not think to add.
A Time. John ties his story to the calendar and to the men in office:
“Forty-six years to build this temple.” Herod began rebuilding the temple about 20 BC. Forty-six years later puts this conversation around AD 27 or 28. That is a detail you can date.
Caiaphas was high priest from about AD 18 to 36. In 1990 workers building a road south of Jerusalem broke into a burial cave. Inside was a bone box inscribed “Joseph son of Caiaphas,” which many scholars believe belonged to this very man. And Pontius Pilate's name was found carved on a stone at Caesarea in 1961, giving his title as prefect of Judea.
Three languages on a sign nailed up in public, where many people read it. This did not happen in a corner.
Here is something Lewis said near the end of his life, as a literary critic. He had spent his whole career reading legends, myths and romances. He said that whatever else John's Gospel is, it is not a legend. Legends do not read like that. Either it is reporting, or someone in the first century invented the modern realistic novel, eighteen hundred years early, and then never used it again.
One more fact. The oldest piece of the New Testament anyone has ever found is a scrap of papyrus the size of a credit card. It is kept in Manchester, England, and is usually dated to the second century. It is from John chapter 18, Jesus standing before Pilate:
“To bear witness to the truth.” The oldest scrap of our New Testament says witness.
That word is the key to John's whole book. Here is something we counted in the Greek New Testament. The verb testify, to bear witness, appears 2 times in Matthew, Mark and Luke put together. In John it appears 33 times. Count the whole word family, witness, testimony, testify, even false witness, and the other three Gospels together have 32. John alone has 47. John is building a court case.
And here is the other count. John uses the verb believe 98 times, more than Matthew, Mark and Luke combined. But the noun faith, John never uses once. Zero. For John, faith is never a thing you have. It is always something you do, and you do it toward a person. 34 times he writes “believe,” followed straight away by a little word that means into: believing into Him.
John is the witness, and he says so, under oath, twice:
And Jesus Himself does not ask for a blind faith. He calls witnesses, like a man on trial: John the Baptist, His works, the Father, and the Scriptures.
“Believe on account of the works themselves.” Jesus points to evidence.
Now the passage people use to prove that faith is supposed to be blind:
“Blessed are those who have not seen and yet have believed.” People hear that as blessed are those who believe without evidence. Read the very next two verses:
“These are written so that you may believe.” Thomas believed because he saw. We believe because Thomas and John saw, and wrote it down. Not seeing is not the same as not knowing. You have never seen George Washington. You believe he lived because of witnesses, records and places you can visit. That is not blind. That is how anyone knows any history at all.
And John is not the only one who says so:
“Most of whom are still alive.” Paul is saying: go and ask them. And then Paul stakes the whole faith on it:
No other faith in the world puts it like that. Paul says that if the event did not happen in history, throw the whole thing away. You do not talk like that about a feeling. You talk like that about a fact.
Even the verse everyone quotes about faith says the same:
The word translated “conviction” is a courtroom word. It means evidence that brings something into the light and settles the case. It is the same word family as reproof in our lesson on correcting one another. Faith is not the absence of evidence. Faith is resting your weight on evidence for what you cannot see yet.
And Lewis would add one more thing. Faith is not deciding to believe without reasons. Faith is holding on to what your reason has already accepted, on the days your feelings say otherwise.
So why do so many good, sincere people hold their faith in Jesus as a blind faith? Be honest with yourself as you read a few reasons:
- We inherited it. We believed what we were raised to believe, and nobody ever showed us why. That is a good start. But it is a borrowed faith until it becomes our own.
- We are afraid questions are disloyal. But Philip said come and see. Jesus showed Thomas His hands. God is not afraid of your questions.
- The world told us faith is a private feeling, and facts are for the public square. Without noticing, we agreed. So we talk about Jesus as if He were a mood, not a Man who had dust on His feet.
- We were handed a Jesus without a place and a time. A picture on a wall instead of a carpenter from Nazareth who stood before Pilate in about AD 30.
Here is why it matters. A blind faith breaks when it is tested, at a hospital bedside, in a college classroom, on the day prayer seems to go unanswered. A faith resting on a real Person, in a real place, at a real time, has something underneath it. You can come back to it on the bad days and find it is still there.
So where does that leave us? Inside every one of us is a law we did not write and cannot keep. Lewis was right about that. That law points to a Lawgiver. And John says the Lawgiver came, walked into Jerusalem, stood before Caiaphas and Pilate, died, and rose. Then He was seen, by men who would rather die than deny it.
Eternal life is not a leap in the dark. It is knowing Someone. Let's pray.
Heavenly Father, You wrote Your law on our hearts, and we have not kept it. Thank You that You did not leave us with a clue but sent us Your Son. He is the Word made flesh, born at a real time and crucified in a real place, and He rose from the dead. Make our faith more than a feeling. Let it rest on the witness You have given us, and hold us fast on the days our feelings fail. In the name of Jesus, Amen.
- The law inside you points to Someone. Everyone knows they ought to be fair, and no one quite is. A stone obeys gravity. A man can break the moral law. A law like that needs a Lawgiver.
- John tells us His name, His town and His dates. The Word became flesh: Jesus of Nazareth, at Bethesda and Siloam, under Caiaphas and Pilate, about AD 30.
- Biblical faith is trust in witnesses, not a leap in the dark. “These are written so that you may believe” (John 20:31).
Counted in the Greek New Testament (SBL edition), by dictionary form:
| Matthew | Mark | Luke | John | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| believe (the verb) | 11 | 14 | 9 | 98 |
| faith (the noun) | 8 | 5 | 11 | 0 |
| testify (the verb) | 1 | 0 | 1 | 33 |
| the whole witness word family | 12 | 11 | 9 | 47 |
In John, believe is followed directly by the word into 34 times: believing into a Person.
- Think of the last argument you heard. What standard were both people appealing to?
- Why can't the law of human nature just be an instinct? What does the piano picture help you see?
- Which detail in John, a person, a place or a time, did you find most striking? Why?
- How would you answer a friend who says, “Blessed are those who have not seen” means faith is supposed to be blind?
- Which of the four reasons for a blind faith do you recognize in yourself? What would it take to move from a borrowed faith to your own?
- Who in your life needs to hear “come and see” this week?
- Romans 1–3; 7 — Paul, about AD 57. Jewish and Gentile believers in Rome. He argues that Gentiles without the Law of Moses still carry a law “written on their hearts.”
- Psalm 19 — David. Israel at worship: God speaks through the sky and through His law.
- Ecclesiastes 3:11 — The Preacher, in the wisdom tradition of Solomon. Israel, wrestling with what life under the sun means.
- Jeremiah 31:33 — Jeremiah, before and during the fall of Jerusalem (586 BC). Judah, promised a new covenant with the law written on the heart.
- John's Gospel — John, son of Zebedee, “the disciple whom Jesus loved”. Believers late in the first century, most of whom never saw Jesus in the flesh. He wrote “so that you may believe” (20:31).
- 1 John 1:1–3 — John, as an old man. Churches he calls “little children.”
- 1 Corinthians 15 — Paul, about AD 54. The church at Corinth, where some were saying there is no resurrection of the dead.
- 2 Peter 1:16 — Peter, near the end of his life. Believers being told the gospel was a story.
- Hebrews 11:1 — An unnamed teacher of the early church. Jewish believers under pressure, tempted to turn back.
- C. S. Lewis, Mere Christianity, Book One (“Right and Wrong as a Clue to the Meaning of the Universe”) and Book Three, chapter “Faith.”
- C. S. Lewis, “Modern Theology and Biblical Criticism,” in Fern-seed and Elephants / Christian Reflections.
- On this site: the Historical Jesus series (six weeks on the evidence for the resurrection).
Teach It Yourself — Free Class Materials
The whole lesson as a printable guide. The Teacher Guide adds timings, delivery notes, what not to say, and where to cut for a 20-minute class. Free to print and use in any church.
|
Did this sermon bless you today? 💚 Give to Support PS Church100% of gifts go to the General Fund — thank you. |